Beyond the Datasheet: Choosing the Right Hyperspectral Camera

By Dr. Rand Swanson, CEO - July 3, 2024

Choosing the right hyperspectral camera involved much more than comparing datasheets. While specifications provide valuable information, selcting the best hyperspectral imaging camera depends on your application, imaging environment, and performance requirements. This guide explains the most important factors to consider when evaluating hyperspectral cameras and hyperspectral imaging technology.

As previously discussed, Resonon offers feasibility studies using customer samples. This is the most reliable way of determining if a hyperspectral camera will meet your needs.

If you are just beginning your search for a hyperspectral camera and sending samples is not an option, you will likely begin by reviewing datasheets. Just as other hyperspectral camera manufacturers do, Resonon provides a detailed data sheet for each of our hyperspectral cameras. In principle, a datasheet enables customers to compare our products with our competitors’ products. In practice, a comparison of data sheets can often be misleading. What truly matters is knowing whether or not the chosen hyperspectral camera will meet your needs.

Figure 1: Key hyperspectral camera attributes for most hyperspectral imaging customers.

The image above highlights the key attributes that are most relevant to many of our customers. Each attribute is a component within our design trade space. The ideal camera depends on the specific problem you are trying to solve (or opportunity you want to seize), and will usually be determined by a subset of these attributes.

Image Quality in a Hyperspectral Camera

Figure 2: The image on the left was recorded with a competitor’s hyperspectral camera and the image on the right was recorded with a Resonon Pika XC2 hyperspectral camera.

Image quality is crucial for some applications, but less so for others. If objects of interest are relatively large and fill a substantial portion of the field of view, high-resolution imaging may not be critical. But, for small features, image quality is essential.

The quality of an image is characterized by the instrument Modulation Transfer Function (MTF), which is typically not provided on datasheets and is also not particularly intuitive. Sample images, as discussed in this blog, are an easy way to visualize the image quality provided by our hyperspectral cameras.

Radiometry and Signal-to-Noise Ratio in Hyperspectral Cameras

Figure 3: Mineral classification maps created from NASA AVIRIS hyperspectral data. Image on the right (after instrument upgrade) shows 4X improvement in SNR as compared to image on the left. Image courtesy of USGS<sup>1</sup>.

Radiometry is how well the instrument collects light, which in turn impacts the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR).

Most datasheets report a single SNR value, even though SNR varies across the camera’s wavelength range. To help our customers make an informed decision, Resonon provides SNR plots for all our cameras.

Radiometry is probably the least obvious important characteristic for many applications. It is more important for hyperspectral cameras than for conventional cameras because a hyperspectral camera divides the signal into many more spectral channels, lowering signal levels. Light-starved data are noisy, diminishing the advantages of additional spectral information provided by hyperspectral cameras.

Additional illumination or slower scan speeds can increase the SNR. However, in situations liked crewed airborne acquisitions, illumination and scan rates are fixed, as adding more sunlight or flying slower than the aircraft's stall speed are not possible. Our feasibility studies help you understand the illumination and scan speeds necessary to achieve the SNR required for your application.

Choosing the Right Frame Rate for Your Hyperspectral Imaging Application

Figure 4: Some hyperspectral applications require “cheetah-like” speed, while others do not.

In our hyperspectral line-scan cameras, the camera speed (aka maximum frame rate) is closely linked to image quality. If an object is scanned using a camera that is too slow, the image will be blurred and/or stretched in one dimension.

In some cases, you can just slow down the scanning speed. In others, like scanning materials on a high-speed conveyor belt, slowing down is not an option and speed becomes a critical factor. Finally, for some applications, like airborne imaging, excess camera speed is effectively wasted because the amount of light available typically determines the maximum data acquisition speed.

This table provides the maximum framerate for all our hyperspectral cameras.

Balancing Size, Weight, and Cost When Selecting a Hyperspectral Camera

Figure 5: Size, mass, and cost are easily available in camera datasheets and quotes.

These characteristics are provided by datasheets and quotes and are easy to understand. Size and mass are critical for applications like airborne drone deployment, but less important for machine vision or laboratory use.

Cost is nearly always a consideration, of course.

Why Software and Ease of Use Matter in Hyperspectral Imaging

Ease of use encompasses hardware, software, and customer service, and it is ALWAYS important.

Our goal is to have you collecting and using hyperspectral data as soon as possible. This includes providing all necessary components, clear assembly instructions and quick-start guides, and hardware designed for intuitive setup and adjustment. We even offer fully-integrated airborne systems with the drone included to eliminate integration burdens for the end-user.

Software ease of use is not a characteristic readily explained on a datasheet. To address this, Resonon provides free Spectronon software and example datacubes. Detailed user manuals, quick-start guides, and tutorial videos are available here to help you get started. For industrial customers and teams who gather large volumes of data, our RVS page features videos demonstrating the user-friendly design.

Figure 6: A training screen in Resonon’s Real-time Vision System (RVS) software. Simple, straightforward tools combined with supplemental video tutorials and user manuals help bring customers up to speed with Resonon software quickly.

Even with all the effort we've put into making our hardware and software user-friendly, questions do sometimes still arise. Resonon customer support is fast, thorough, and dedicated to helping you successfully use our products.

Which Hyperspectral Camera Specifications Actually Matter?33

You may have noted that some of the commonly-touted hyperspectral camera specifications, such as distortions and spot sizes, were not listed as key attributes. These specifications do a play major role in instrument performance, and we don’t want to diminish their importance.

However, for most customers trying to choose the right hyperspectral camera for their application, direct comparison of these types of specifications is less relevant than the six key attributes we’ve highlighted here.

Key Takeaways

Choose a camera based on your application, not just the datasheet.
Evaluate image quality alongside radiometric performance.
Consider software, training, and support.
Review complete SNR data instead of a single published value.
Test your application through a feasibility study whenever possible.

References

1. Effects of spectrometer band pass, sampling, and signal-to-noise ratio on spectral identification using the Tetracorder algorithm.

Swayze, G. A., R. N. Clark, A. F. H. Goetz, T. G. Chrien, and N. S. Gorelick (2003), J. Geophys. Res., 108, 5105, doi:10.1029/2002JE001975, E9.

Contact us

If you’d like to discuss the attributes most important to your application, please reach out to a member of our Sales Team.

Dr. Rand Swanson

CEO

Rand Swanson is the Chief Executive Officer and co-founder of Resonon. Along with overseeing company management, he applies his decades of expertise to optical design and radiometric modeling for commercial and R&D projects.

Working alongside the talented and dynamic Resonon team, he feels fortunate to focus his efforts on hyperspectral imaging—a technology that is simple in concept, complex in execution, and capable of solving many challenging problems.

More articles by Rand:

ARCSTONE Hyperspectral Instrument Launch Will Hyperspectral Imaging Work for My Application?